Water Garden Journal
The Perception of Color
David thought the waterlily ‘Vesuve’ was red. A customer saw pink. Their disagreement gets at how tricky it is to name the color of a flower.
Original publication: Summer 2008

By David Curtright
One of the most interesting and, to be truthful, frustrating, things about selling plants to the public is that people perceive colors in very different ways, often in ways that challenge my sense of familiarity with common colors. The perception of color is so subjective that I sometimes wonder if there is any reason to mention color in our descriptions of plants. Beyond telling the difference between purple and yellow, or blue and red, descriptions fall victim to the subtleties of what people see, and such vagaries are hardly to be understood. My wife and I debate about what is green and what is blue. We acknowledge that the sky is usually blue and that grass is usually green, but when it comes to shades of teal and turquoise, or chartreuse and sea green, all bets are off. Each of us knows that we are right, and that there will be no convincing the other of their error, so we allow it to lie there in a corner of our lives until we find another ambiguous shade of either color to debate.
This matter has been brought to my attention at least three times recently. I won’t list them all, but in one instance I was showing a woman hardy waterlilies. She had said that she wanted red, so I showed her a specimen of ‘Vesuve’, which is about as red as it needs to be, I think. She didn’t want that one, it was pink and she wanted red, and declared that she didn’t see any, even though she was surrounded by tanks full of ‘Attraction’, ‘Vesuve’, ‘Steven Strawn’, and a few others. I hardly knew how to behave. I showed her what I call pink, ‘Rose Arey’, ‘Anne Epple’, and ‘Mayla’, and she agreed that they were pink, but said that the others were not red. I was flabbergasted. She got the ‘Vesuve’ eventually, but she left thinking that it was more pink than red. My assistant suffers the same sort of color blindness, telling me that ‘Escarboucle’ is red with purple in it. He has begun to make a joke out of how it would be nice to get a red waterlily for his pond some day.
All of this points to the near impossibility of sorting flowers by color for the purposes of naming them accurately. I have tried with limited success to sort waterlilies by what I understand to be the colors that they exhibit, using guides provided by various authors to help me along. I once got lucky enough to have Walter Pagels come by one of my ponds to identify my plants using the R.H.S. (Royal Horticultural Society) color chips. We had Slocum and Robinson’s book to tell us what we were supposed to be seeing. We pegged a few of them, but for the most part, identities were concluded with something like, “Well, it’s hard to tell. Just call it another unknown red.”
I say lucky enough not because I was able to get Walter out to one of my ponds. That was not too difficult. I was most fortunate because we had the RHS color guides with us. They are about as rare as first edition Gutenberg Bibles, but Members can borrow a set from Walter, the IWGS Librarian – wpagels@aol.com. They are cumbersome and easily damaged, and so are about as useful to the average grower of aquatic plants as if they were a bucket of lard. What we need is another system of color standards. It should be something that everybody has easy access to and that is recognized as some sort of authority on color.
There are many sources for color standards, but only a few of them are nearly universally familiar to people. I would suggest, perhaps, Crayola crayons, which have become ubiquitous in the world, and whose color standards probably have not changed for some time. Some of the names might be fanciful, but so what? At least everybody would know more about what they were seeing when they encounter color descriptions such as, “Cardinal Red,” than they do when they read entries like, “R.H.S. Chart: Fan 2, Violet-Blue Group, No. 92C,” which means absolutely nothing to most people.
Doing this would increase our chances of sorting the waterlilies, Irises, and other plants that are in the hobby, and among which there is confusion. Of course, there is always the issue of how people see the color standards, but you’ve got to draw the line somewhere and at least they would have a color standard to look at.
Publication details
Originally published in Water Garden Journal, Summer 2008.

