Water Garden Journal

What Are We Doing?

Spring at the nursery means deciding what to propagate. It also gives David reason to think about where those plants might end up and what happens if they escape into waterways.

Original publication: Spring 2013

Pond with reeds - geograph.org.uk - 7362276
Reference photograph. Aleks Scholz  · Source · CC BY-SA 2.0

By David Curtright

Grower’s Corner, Water Garden Journal, Spring 2013, volume 28, number 1, pages 12–13.

This is the season when those of us who grow and sell water-loving plants for a living are propagating plants as fast as we can, and wondering what sort of season we’re going to have. As I do this work, cleaning tanks, killing weeds, mixing soil, deciding what to grow and what not to bother with, I am always cognizant of a particular issue that has affected our industry recently, but I am aware of it even more acutely this year because of the recurrent discussions on line. The matter of which I speak is that of invasive species being sent into sensitive areas.

Strictly speaking, I am not a purist in this matter, but I have long been of the opinion that the nursery industry as a whole, and our part of it is no exception, has a lot to answer for in terms of the number of species that have been introduced into areas not accustomed to their presence. Usually, this is not a problem. Species go into areas in which they can’t reproduce, or even live for long, and so are dead ends. They will never become a problem in most areas. But then there are those species that, once introduced, run rough-shod over an entire region. Plants such as Lythrum salicaria, a native of Europe, have become hugely invasive in the upper Midwest because they produce so many seeds that are easily disseminated throughout a waterway or wetland. In their natural state, they probably lose many of those seeds to a beetle, or are somehow limited in their survivability, but, unchallenged, they are a menace, however attractive they might be. Beauty is as beauty does.

Whatever the plant (or animal), and whatever the medium in which it grows, the problem is the same. Ecosystems are disrupted by the introduction of a foreign component. One might ask, “Well, so what if the Mentha aquatica (for instance) hybridizes with the native Mentha, you still have a Mentha in the area.” True enough. It is, nevertheless, different, and organisms that might live quite nicely in the presence of the native species, might not be able to use the new plant as well for some subtle reason, and so will be put at some disadvantage. The disruptions compound, and the change might be irrevocable. Biodiversity is compromised, and so evolution is disrupted.

Many of us that are in the business of growing plants for a living do so because we love plants, specifi cally, but the natural world, generally. We enjoy being able to go into an unspoiled area, and to feel and to learn what it is to be an inhabitant of this remarkable planet. We decry the abuses that we see being brought down upon our beloved Earth, and we donate to causes that seek to mitigate these usurpations of the natural order. We nod our heads in concurrence when the conversation goes the subject of environmental concerns, and we agree that we hope that humanity will get its act together before it destroys itself and most of what is left in the bargain.

And yet, and yet, we sell plants and animals as fast as we can, and in the greatest quantities possible. We know, at least we do in those moments when we slow down enough to think about it, that we are transgressing, and we hope that this state or that will not ban a particular weed (and let’s face it, almost all of these plants are weeds someplace) before we can get in another season of easy money. We whine about it when certain states proscribe a particular species (think Hyacinth), or even announces that it is thinking of doing so.

I say that the “glory days” might be over for certain plants, and we need to get used to that idea. When Minnesota declared that they didn’t want to see any more Eichhornia crassipes come into the state, nobody could believe it. We stood in groups and slapped our brows in disbelief, joking about how we have a diffi cult time keeping it alive in southern California over winter, and to think that it might over-winter in Minnesota was near insanity.

I’ve never been to Minnesota. I have no idea what will or will not survive there. I had my mind blown one day in Michigan when I saw Cannas coming up in a roadside planter in early March, so what do I know? Maybe the people in Minnesota who pay attention to these things know more than the growers in California, or Florida, or Texas, or any place other than Minnesota. I would think that the motivation of the people in Minnesota to take such action is well-intentioned and laudable. I would doubt that on the day that they announced their intentions nobody went to work thinking that this was his big chance to mess with growers to his south, and so I won’t send any more Hyacinths into Minnesota or into any other state that asks me not to. Yes, sales will suffer for it, and that’s a shame for me, but it might save the people of Minnesota millions of dollars in eradication efforts.

I don’t mean to deride the industry, or the people in it. I love what I do. I consider myself to be among the fortunate of Earth to be able to make a living at my hobby. I consider everybody that I’ve met in the hobby and industry to be good people, and while I do not want to paint with too broad a brush, I do think that we need to think about the consequences of what we do, vis-à-vis the continued well-being of our world. Not the planet, which will do just fi ne no matter what we do, but our world, which we have the power to preserve or to destroy. I once had the temerity to suggest in an online discussion about heated pots that we might just say that growing a tropical lily in Switzerland might require some sacrifi ces, among them being a short season, and that a person might have to either store the tubers properly, or to buy new ones each season. I further said that we might, as hobbyists, think about how many plastic containers of bacteria, or fi sh food, or whatever, we go through, and perhaps try to reduce that number. In approximately equal measures, I was both castigated for becoming too political (?!), and praised for having raised an important issue. So I am under no illusions that this essay will go by unnoticed. Nevertheless, I believe that these things must be said at some point in this discussion.

When we were in Texas for our symposium, the matter of Texas’ white list was the hot topic of the day. Nobody said one single word in defense of preserving the natural order of things. I’ve seen no discussion of this aspect of the argument in the online discussions that have been going on, and I am saddened by that fact.

We need to arrive at a compromise position on this. We do ourselves no favors by being recalcitrant, in my opinion, and so we need to agree that certain plants should not go into certain areas, regardless of how much money we lose by saying so. It’s only money, and that can be made in several other ways. Self-control and humility might be useful in this instance, and I would hope that we will learn to respect the edicts of people who act with specifi c knowledge of their situations, and to look for other ways to earn our lucre.

Publication details

Originally published in Water Garden Journal, Spring 2013.