Water Garden Journal
Seeds or Cuttings?
When bog plants start going dormant, David gathers seed and takes cuttings. What he collects in autumn helps stock the nursery the following spring.
Original publication: Winter 2006

By David Curtright
Grower’s Corner, Water Garden Journal, Winter 2006, volume 21, number 4, page 6.
As autumn descends, many bog plants finish producing seeds as they go dormant, and anybody interested in propagating plants cannot help feeling the pull of those seeds to be collected and then sown in a commodious spot so that they can grow. I make it a point to succumb to that pull every year. Some seeds can be sown immediately, but many must be chilled, which leads to delays in being able to begin growing plants for an upcoming season. Obviously, producing plants from seeds yields more plants than any other method, and some plants are best propagated by seed, but for the interim between when I can grow plants outside in the summer, and the time when I can sow seeds in late winter, I use another means of propagation— divisions and cuttings.
For many years I have maintained my populations of several species by cutting plants such as Saururus spp., Lobelia, or Phalaris arundinacea variegata just before they go dormant. I can produce many plantlets in very short order. This allows me to have dozens of plants growing in late winter/early spring, which gives my customers a better selection to choose from than they might otherwise have early in the season. Besides, I can’t stand to see all of those plants die unused.
The method is simple, really. I merely cut the stems a few inches above the substrate, clip the leaves off, leaving about a half inch of the petiole or leaf blade, and lay the cuttings on their sides in shallow water. Within two weeks in most cases, new plants emerge from the leaf axils, quickly sprouting roots and leaves. The well-developed young plants can be removed and potted as soon as they have good roots and come away from the parent stem easily. They can frequently go directly into the pot in which they will be sold, unlike many seedlings, which might go through as many as two or three potting stages.
For plants such as Eichhornia paniculata, or Sagittaria montevidensis, which produce small plants at their bases as they grow in the summer, pulling the plants in the fall can yield several offspring. In the greenhouse, I can keep them growing, or maintain them in stasis for the winter, and then bring them out early in the next season, already established in their pots. Here in southern California, we cannot keep E. paniculata alive over winter, and seeds are too slow for me. They germinate slowly, grow slowly, and are finally ready for market in August, which is too late to sell a plant that is an annual. My method of separating them in October, then potting them in old soil, keeping them in shallow water, and high in the greenhouse, yields marketable plants in March.
This is also a good time to work with potted plants such as Typha spp. It is possible to glean as many as fifty new starts of T. laxmannii, or Sagittaria tubers from a 2-gallon potting. I always have a few pottings of T. laxmannii at the end of each season from my clients’ formal ponds, and I set them up for just this purpose. Splitting them up and growing them in the greenhouse now, rather than waiting for them to begin to grow in the spring can mean having plants available as early as late February. Also, harvesting and storing or growing them can protect them from animals or fungus.
However growers who obtain growing stock, cuttings, seeds, or even pre-grown plugs, he must fit the method to their needs, time constraints, and to the facilities in which the plants will be grown in order to avoid waste. It is easy to produce thousands of specimens of some plants, but if you only sell hundreds, or dozens of them, then it is overkill. It is possible to have a sale on those plants that we have too many of, but even so, it is better to tailor the method to the need. My use of cuttings at the end of the season fills both my need for new plant material, and my need to succumb to the pull of those plants as autumn descends.
Publication details
Originally published in Water Garden Journal, Winter 2006.

