Guides & stories
Tropical fish in planted ponds
David tried tropical fish in planted ponds in the 1980s. He was looking for fish that could live among the plants without constantly stirring up the water.

A different choice of pond fish
David’s daughter Genevieve remembers those ponds from the 1980s. Her father wanted clear water and healthy plants, and he paid close attention to what the fish did around the pots.
That interest continued into his published writing. His 2009 article, Pond and Water Gardening Animals, describes tropical fish living with koi in a large pond where aquatic plants flourished.
The balance of a planted pond
In David’s account, the pond changed after swans were introduced. The planting and maintenance problems that followed were part of a change in the whole animal population.
Think about how the fish will live among the plants. How much will they eat, where will they feed, and how much extra debris and waste will you have to remove?
Know the fish before choosing the pond
Tropical fish are a broad group, with different adult sizes, diets, behaviors, and temperature needs. A fish that thrives in one pond may be poorly suited to another, even in the same garden.
Before you bring tropical fish outdoors, check the needs of the species you’re considering and how you’ll meet them as the seasons change. A warm afternoon tells you little about the temperature on a cold night.
Watch what happens around the plants
Look at the fish among the planting. Are they disturbing exposed growing media? Are leaves or stems being damaged? Does the water cloud where they feed? Those observations are more useful than choosing fish by a broad category alone.
David’s pond account offers one example of fish and plants living together, and of what happened when that arrangement changed. Read the complete story here, or explore the guides to bottom foraging and keeping koi and goldfish around aquatic plants.



